This criticism is highly relevant to the current LD topic. It also has permanent value as a detailed critique of nuclear war reps. It argues that melancholy over Hiroshima and Nagasaki is the only appropriate response to discussions of nuclear weapons.
This was the primary affirmative and negative argument deployed by the Georgetown team of Max Hantel and Hao Shen for a full year, including a semifinals run at the Wake Forest tournament.
Further coaching advice available for master subscribers!
Qualified Immunity File – LD – November
October 17, 2016
Extremely comprehensive and thorough file from Sherry Hall on the latest criminal justice LD topic.
This is the Trash K. It’s a popular argument from previous college topics.
It says that the affirmative attempts to erase the inevitable waste that accompanies processes like nuclear power. It is applicable to affs that claim to solve waste through processes like “nuclear recycling” or “vitrification” or “integral fast reactors.” It’s sort of a staple of hot new nuclear technology that the proponents will claim to erase the waste problem.
I think this will really help to bolster many of your critical positions. Thanks for reading!